I was thinking that this article might warrant its own discussion. I know we're all 'wearing purple goggles' here, but I think the ranking for Bridgewater is pretty low. If you are doing a subjective ranking (that is, not just going off of QB rankings and such) I don't see how you wouldn't put Bridgewater higher.
1. Aaron Rodgers (5)
2. Tom Brady (4)
3. Ben Roethlisberger (6)
4. Peyton Manning (1)
5. Tony Romo (12)
6. Andrew Luck (7)
You can't argue that these guys don't deserve to be at the top.
7. Philip Rivers (2)
8. Russell Wilson (6)
9. Matt Ryan (11)
10. Drew Brees (3)
I think Wilson is a great QB, without many weapons to throw to, and an offense that is run-first. I think he is elite, and belongs in the upper group. Rivers is flawed to me, and Ryan seems more like a stat guy than a winner (like Stafford, down further). Still, from a historical perspective, I can see these guys being above Teddy.
11. Joe Flacco (16)
12. Eli Manning (20)
13. Ryan Tannehill (14)
14. Cam Newton (8)
15. Alex Smith (17)
16. Colin Kaepernick (15)
17. Matthew Stafford (13)
18. Teddy Bridgewater (N/A)
Here's where I start to raise my eyebrows. Flacco and Manning are hard to judge - great playoff QB's who tend to be pretty erratic regular season QB's. Are they lucky in the playoffs, or does their game truly rise to Hall of Fame levels for elimination games? Kaepernick?!? I thought Kyle Orton outplayed him for most of the season. The 49'ers offense was pretty bad, much worse than ours, despite having a better offensive line, two better running backs (Gore and Hyde), and probably better receivers (Vernon Davis, Crabtree, Boldin).
The rest of the guys (13-17) - I wouldn't want any of them on my team if I was hoping to win a Superbowl. So for me, on this list, I have Teddy as #12 (with Matt Ryan just below him).
The other question that comes to mind is: "Who would you trade Teddy Bridgewater for, one for one, on this list?" For me, given the age of so many of the top QB's, I would only choose Rodgers, Wilson, and Luck (...and Luck was pretty ordinary at the end of the year). I wouldn't give up a potential decade of great QB play of Tom Brady's last two "elite" years - at least, not with this offensive line giving up sacks at this rate.