JEC334 wrote:Well you should watch some previous game tape. From what I have seen, he is most effective in the middle.
Show me some tape where he's lined up outside. Of COURSE he's most effective in the middle when that's where he's playing 95% of his snaps. He really, rarely got the opportunity.
I have seldom seen Harvin able to streak on the outside for a catch.
Uhh...because he's not lined up outside and his routes primarily take him over the middle?
I seldom seen him catch the ball in traffic.

NOW who needs to watch tape?
I still think he was still more effective as a kick returner than a WR.
Why can't he be great at both? And please, the dude was on his way to being a top-15 receiver before his injury. Heck, he was being talked about as a dark horse for league MVP (based on his receiving primarily, since that's what he did most, but also as a returner). In my mind saying he was better at one over the other is splitting hairs.
Patterson is just as effective as Harvin in the return game
Right. Considering all of his NFL experience!
Look, he has that potential, but until he proves it on the field in an NFL game all it is is potential. He's proven nothing.
and is able to go for the deep ball unlike Percy.
We're going to have to agree to disagree. There's a difference between not being asked to run a post pattern and not being able to run it effectively.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TQksfBI1h-4
(see 4:10; 5:10; 6:09; 8:02; 8:36; 10:37)
If Patterson can measure up to Percy with the ball in his hands that's going to be amazing. He has some big shoes to fill.