HardcoreVikesFan wrote:
2 fathers and 2 sons go fishing. Each of them catches one fish. So why do they bring home only 3 fishes?
A man, his father and his son go fishing. He and his father are both fathers, so we have 2 fathers and he and his son are both sons so we have 2 sons, yet if each catches a fish there are only 3 fishes.
Of course, the eldest is also a son so techincally I think we have 2 fathers and 3 sons, but I guess you can't claim son status for the sake of the riddle unless your father is actually there...
BTW, on the hole one, I had heard that before which is why I was pretty sure my guess of flame was wrong-- I just couldn't recall the right answer. Still I think flame/photon are pretty good solutions to the question. I had always taken the answer that if you put a hole in a barrel of sand or water or whatever, it will get lighter because its contents will escape. However you frame it, it's a decent riddle. Still, can you really 'see' a hole in the absence of the thing the hole is in?
Anyway, here is a reasonably complicated one.
A man comes upon 3 boys playing and notices that all three of them have dirt smudges on their forehead. He tells the lads that at least one of you has a dirt smudge on your forehead. Without feeling, if you can tell me if you do or don't and be correct and explain how you knew, I'll give you a quarter. The three boys stare at each other for a while thinking hard. After another slight pause one boy raises his hand and declares that he had a smudge. The man was dumbfounded, but had to relinquish the quarter after hearing the boys reasoning. What did the boy say? (BTW there is not a reflection to be found in this joke-- no mirrors, sunglasses, etc... this is a logic riddle)